A RAMS that comes back with comments costs time on both sides. The start date slips, the subcontractor waits, and someone has to rewrite and resubmit. Most rejections come down to the same handful of problems, and most of them can be avoided before the RAMS is sent.
Why principal contractors review RAMS
Under regulation 13 of CDM 2015 (opens in a new tab), the principal contractor must plan, manage, monitor and coordinate the construction phase, and coordinate how contractors apply health and safety requirements. Each contractor, under regulation 15 (opens in a new tab), must follow the principal contractor's directions and the relevant parts of the construction phase plan.
Reviewing RAMS is one of the main ways principal contractors check that each contractor's work fits the site's plan. It's a check, not a transfer of responsibility: the contractor remains responsible for its own risk assessment and method.
The common reasons RAMS are rejected
The reasons below are based on what principal contractors commonly ask for. We haven't measured how often each one happens.
1. It's not specific to the site or task
The most common problem. Tell-tale signs:
- another site's name or address left in
- a scope of work that describes the trade in general, not this job
- hazards that don't apply, and real hazards missing
- emergency arrangements that point to the wrong hospital
A reviewer can usually spot a copied RAMS within a minute. See RAMS vs risk assessment vs method statement for why a general risk assessment isn't enough.
2. It doesn't meet the principal contractor's minimum standards
Many principal contractors set requirements above the legal minimum: specific PPE, banned equipment, permit systems, exclusion zones, or rules for particular activities. A RAMS that doesn't reflect them will come back, even if it would be acceptable elsewhere. Read the site's construction phase plan and minimum standards before writing, not after.
3. The sequence of work is vague
"Install units as per manufacturer's instructions" isn't a method. The reviewer needs to see how the work will actually be done: delivery, storage, lifting, access, the installation itself, and clearing up. Where the manufacturer's instructions matter, say what they require.
4. The controls don't match the hazards
Common examples:
- PPE listed as the main control for a hazard that could be engineered out
- no rescue plan for work at height
- no control for dust from cutting
- generic controls copied for every hazard
5. Competence isn't shown
The RAMS should name the supervisor and say what cards, tickets and training the work needs. Regulation 15(7) (opens in a new tab) requires contractors to appoint only people with, or getting, the skills, knowledge, training and experience for the task. If the RAMS relies on an IPAF-trained operator, say so, and make sure the people on site actually hold the card.
6. Plant and equipment details are missing
Reviewers look for the actual equipment, and evidence it's safe to use: thorough examination records for lifting equipment (under LOLER), inspection records for other work equipment where needed (under PUWER), and who is trained to use it.
7. COSHH is missing or just a data sheet
Every hazardous substance needs a COSHH assessment, not just its safety data sheet. Our COSHH guide for subcontractors explains the difference.
8. Housekeeping problems
Small things that still get a RAMS sent back:
- no revision number or date
- not signed by the person who approved it
- out of date, or past the site's review period
- no briefing record
Talk to the principal contractor early
Many rejections can be avoided with a short conversation before the RAMS is written. Ask the principal contractor's site team:
- whether they have a RAMS template, or particular sections they expect
- which of their minimum standards apply to your work
- whether any permits are needed, such as for hot works, work at height or breaking ground
- who will review the RAMS, and how long they usually take
- how they want amendments submitted
Asking these questions at the start also helps the principal contractor plan your work alongside other trades, which is part of their coordination duty. If you're a tier-2 contractor collecting RAMS from your own subcontractors, pass the same information down before they start writing, rather than finding the gaps when their RAMS arrives on your desk.
A checklist before you submit
- The site name, address and principal contractor are correct everywhere
- The scope describes this task, in this location, on this site
- The sequence of work is step by step and matches what will happen
- Every significant hazard has a control, following the hierarchy
- The principal contractor's minimum standards and site rules are reflected
- The supervisor and the required competencies are named
- Plant, equipment and inspection details are included
- Every hazardous substance has a COSHH assessment
- Emergency arrangements are specific to this site
- It has a revision number, date and approval signature
When a RAMS comes back
Treat the comments as a revision, not a patch:
- Read every comment, and ask the reviewer if anything is unclear.
- Update the RAMS and record the change as a new revision.
- Have it approved again by your competent person before resubmitting.
- If the change affects the work, brief the team again.
For more on when a RAMS needs a new revision, see how often RAMS should be reviewed.
Getting it right first time
Ramvio drafts RAMS from the task, the site rules and the principal contractor's own requirements, and shows which requirements the draft covers, so gaps are visible before submission. Your competent person still reviews and approves every RAMS. If you'd like to try it, ask for early access.
Further reading: the HSE's guidance on CDM 2015 (opens in a new tab) and its legal guidance, L153 (opens in a new tab).